8.11 Darkness on the Edge of Town Roundtable

1) Favorite quote of the episode?

LizzyB: Definitely Brooke’s “I love you” right before her head went beneath the water. Quinn’s “I’m your storm” was a close second.

Amanda: Brooke when she is saying “he’s just a boy” Something about how she says those lines…

2) Whose storyline was scarier: Brooke, Jamie and Julian’s or Quinn’s?

LizzyB: I have to go with the former because there was a child involved. The whole thing gave me chills.

Amanda: The first. Children involved and then being stuck in water. Panic!

3) Was this the most intense OTH car accident to date?

LizzyB: I have to say yes because they spent the whole episode on it. Though, for me, no one part beats the look on Nathan and Haley’s faces right before Nate dove into the water to save Cooper and Rachel in Season 3.

Amanda: I am going to agree with Lizzy.

4) Did you think anyone was going to die? If so, who?

LizzyB: Not going to lie…I knew Brooke wasn’t dying but, for a hot second, I wasn’t sure about Lauren and I actually thought that about Quinn when I saw her legs in the pool.

Amanda: Ok I knew as well about Brooke  too but when Quinn was laying in the pool I thought for a second. Oh no!

5) Who was your favorite hero of the night?

LizzyB: Brooke and Quinn were definitely bad ass but my heart broke for Julian with every scene, from him jumping in the river to save Brooke and Jamie, to him screaming under water when he saw Brooke was unconscious to him yelling at Brooke to wake up while performing CPR. Mad props to Austin last night, he was awesome and totally had me crying…even though I knew there was no way Brooke was dying.

Amanda: Julian certainly won my heart with his parts but I also really enjoyed watching Brooke. She was strong and resourceful and these were things I felt she has been lacking in the last few episodes due to the loss of her company so I liked watching her kick in to gear and be a hero.

6) Has Tree Hill seen its last psycho killer?

LizzyB: HA! Not even if this really is the last season!!!

Amanda: See above answer

Bonus Question: What are your hopes for the second half of the season?

LizzyB: More Naley awesomeness and more Skillz. And no more crazy Katie please!

Amanda: If this is the last season then I hope to see some closure for all and happiness too (i know it sounds a little cheesy)