9.05 The Killing Moon Reaction

I’m repeating myself, but definitley best episode of the season so far i was worried. First paul/joy were amazing love them together…the final season amazing. WHO HAS NATE???? naley have been through enough and now he’s being kidnapped why? glad to see strong brooke back, feel bad for julian. Chris funny, nice to see millie/brooke in a scene with their banter. Also, the scene when chase/chuck playing basketball look behind them its lucas’s house. Curious to see how this all plays out.

Great episode! Loved everything. Season nine is really like old school OTH!

correction i meant to say final SCENE was amazing

Ok this season is amazing so far! Episode 3 i wasnt to happy with it and the lack of substance, but the past two weeks have been incredible! Loving the Haley/Dan scenes, cant wait to get into the kidnapping a lot more! and yeah s* i think thats been the general consensus for the past few months that Dan will die saving Nathan. Everyones known that for the past few months haha. Its the only logical plot, and in my opinion its really te only way Dan can get his retribution. Thats what Dan Scott is about, and he has to die saving Nathan or any of his family members to be finally forgiven. Cant wait!!!

Logan is the son of Clay and Sara…Book it.

agreed&^

@brad — that’s what i’m saying too! i think his son died somehow and he’s blocked it out… or he was taken away after sara died. it doesn’t seem like a place where a little boy would be — also, no one else is ever in their scenes together!

9.05: The Killing Moon, more like The Killing Hour!!! This is how I like my Tree Hill! Fun, Flirty, Dark and Dirty! Great episode. Progression on every story! While some stories are meatier than others, they all have purpose. So lets get to it (gonna go by character – so it might be a tad on the LOOOOONG side)

Julian: Oh my heart! I really feel bad for this guy. Between the hospital, the note and the drunken bar fights, I love this Julian sooooo much more than the butterfly catching not knowing how many innings are in a baseball game Julian. Austin is def showing us his acting chops!

Brooke: Ha! Love her confronting that Tara bitch and Millie was too funny “Look up Bitch and there is Brooke”! Loved it! I miss Millie and Brooke together. Soooo glad we got to see some of it! Brooke destroying the cafe was nothing new, but nice to see what got us there. Stupid Tara slut!

Tara: She could have kept her face to face “friend request” cockroaches in her own damn cafe. I really dont like this girl. At all! Then the low blow note to Julian just made me want to kick her ass! Hopefully she goes away SOON!!!!

Chase: You dirty dog you! To be such an ass about the Tara thing then there for Chuck! I am soo confused on who you are. Are you a bad boy who does good things sometimes or a good guy who does shitty things sometimes? However, loved you calling Keller out on his douchbaginess!!

Chuck: I ACTUALLYYYYY liked you this ep. Thanks for showing up! Kid Keller has my permission to stay! However, your “father” not so much. That guy is bad news!

Chris: Loved you being there for Hailes! Your comedic timing is perfect. You are simply amazing as an ass! You can stay too!

Logan: You are too cute for words!

Jamie: I wish they would tell him already!! Like come on guys! Loved seeing him hang out with Quinn again! Reminded me of the Treasure hunt episode!

Quinn: This is the year I fall back in love with Quinn! Amazing job this season! And your hair color is BEAUTIFUL!!!

Clay: Crazy Party of 1!!! Glad I actually like this storyline. Welcome back Clay! I cant wait to figure out what he is hiding! Hopfully it is worth the effort and jorney we have taken to get there!

Dan: The best thing about Dan is, well EVERYTHING!!!!! This is the perfect storyline for him. His talk with Quinn was great! His admssion of the fire and wanting to be by his family is great! His altercation with Haley was phenom. I want to believe he is a good man! I really do….. But can we???

Haley: Standout preformance of the night! The police station with Chris, the airport where she breaks down, then confronting Dan, and calling the police! BJG is quite the actress! She really makes me feel it! I believe she is Haley James Scott and her husband is missing! Bethany who??? So the question is, where exactally is Nathan????

I give the ep a 9! Really good stuff this ep! This is shaping up to be one amazing season! Thanks for the treat CW and Mark and Cast and Crew! This is how to end a show!

Best episode of the season.. yes. But with the other 4 terrible episodes how hard is it to be the best? Not much.

When this is factored in to the hundreds of other great One Tree Hill episodes is 9.05 the one you are going to pull put of your DVD case and rewatch over and over? Is 9.05 the one you will always remember the lines to? Probably not.

I guess this season is better then anything in season 7 or 8 though. I’ll probably never get those on DVD unless I get a really good deal on amazon.

Amanda what scene were you in?

Looking forward to 9.07 and a return of Lucas/Chad and his hipster hair he had been hiding under that beanie for two years.

This episode wasn’t as awful as the others have been… but to me, it still wasn’t great by any means. I feel like it was just a LOT of filler stuff, mixed in with only a couple decent scenes. The only parts that really stood out to me as being somewhat decent were Haley’s scenes.

I still think the whole “Nathan missing” storyline is dumb, and repetitive (considering all the other lame psycho/kidnapping stuff this show has come up with). But man, BJG is rocking it! She is such an amazing actress, and this storyline is really proving just how talented she really is. She really deserves some time in the spot light, after being basically a prop over the last couple of seasons lol. So I’m happy that she’s finally getting to shine a little bit. And she’s doing an amazing job!

I was actually pleasantly surprised, andimpressed with Chris Keller in this episode. Well, atleast during his serious parts, when he was helping Haley. It’s nice to see that side of him for a change. The “creepy perv 24/7″ stuff gets old.

And the rest was just… blahhhh:

-Haley going after Dan as a suspect in Nathan’s disappearance is so predictable. *yawn*

-Chuck needs to leave, like now. Nobody cares about your dad coming home, or the fact that Chase feels left out of your life now. Good grief.

-Clay’s mental illness storyline is already getting so old. Not to mention that it’s just random as hell. It’s moving sooo slow, and they really need to get to the point and move on already.

-Same with Julian’s “guilt” storyline. It was somewhat interesting, and even necessary for one episode… but there’s no need to drag it out any longer than that.

-The rival cafe drama is just silly, and yet another waste of a storyline for the FINAL season. But I will say that I love that we’re finally seeing old, feisty Brooke again! Her scenes are the only entertaining part of this storyline.

-And the Chris/Tara/Chase triangle? Ridiculous, plain and simple.

So yeah. Pretty much this season is just all over the place, in my opinion. And it’s the furthest thing from what I feel these final 13 episodes SHOULD be about… closure. :/

Nathan has been captured by the drug lord guy Dan approached on the playground. But his higher ups. They are trying to make this out to be bigger than it is but its quite simple. Dan is going to eventually save Nathan and in the process someone on the good side will die (money is on Dan). Makes sense too. The only way to completely make up for what he did to Keith is to sacrifice himself in the highest way.

Clays storyline has nothing to do with Nathan in anyway. My take is Sara and Clay had child and after Sara he left it all to go to tree hill. He thought he couldn’t care for the kid without Sara so he leaves to the kid with relatives. Its what no one not even himself knows about. Maybe its Logan(i think it is) but eventually the kid will reappear and Quinn will adopt the child.