Season 5 5.17 Hate is Safer than Love Spoilers

Written By: Mark Schwahn
Directed By: Stuart Gillard

General Plot

With Brooke’s baby in need of emergency surgery and Haley torn over returning to the music scene, now isn’t really the time for Lucas to be dropping any bombshells on Peyton. But when heartbreaking news hits, he may not be able to stay mum for much longer.

Source: TVGuide

Lucas is hurt by devastating news, and he makes a surprising revelation to Peyton. Elsewhere, Brooke’s foster baby has an emergency operation; and Skills and Nathan take a risk as they try to turn the Ravens’ season around. TVGuide via +supernova+ @ FFEpisode 5.17 [Airing May 12]: During halftime of a game, Lindsey calls Lucas who tells her he wished she came tonight. Lindsey tells Lucas something that leaves him speechless. During the game, he pushes Quentin to his limits. At the end of the episode, Lucas tells Peyton that he hates her and whishes she had never come back. Angie undergoes surgery. A doctor tells Dan that he is number two on the donor recipient list to get a new hear. Brooke, Haley, Jamie, Skills, Nathan, and Mouth also appear. Source: SpoilerFix.com

Lucas (Chad Michael Murray) is crushed by devastating news, while Brooke’s (Sophia Bush) baby undergoes emergency surgery. Haley (Bethany Joy Galeotti) wrestles with her decision to record a new album. Skills (Antwon Tanner) and Nathan (James Lafferty) employ a risky game plan to salvage the Raven’s season and Lucas stuns Peyton (Hilarie Burton) with a shocking truth. Lee Norris also stars. Stuart Gillard directed the episode written by Mark Schwahn

Devastating news crushes Lucas; Brooke’s baby undergoes emergency surgery; Haley wrestles with her decision to record a new album; Lucas stuns Peyton with a shocking truth.

General Spoilers

Though previews for next week’s One Tree Hill seemed to indicate a bedroom reunion for Peyton and Lucas, I’m told he’s still very much in love with Lindsey, and when things with the book editor go from bad to worse, Luke wholeheartedly blames Peyton. Expect to see some ugly moments from him in the next week or two… on the basketball court and off.

Source: Zap2It

Credit: rileycat @ othforums.com
I know there has been a lot of speculation about what Lindsay tells Lucas on the phone in 517, so I thought I would share what I know. My friend and I were extras in 518 and she heard Lindsay say that she was lying when she told Lucas she was seeing someone else. I didn’t hear her but I was behind my friend when we were walking behind Lindsay. I did hear her say “You asked me if I missed you…..the truth is I miss you everyday.” It was pretty much like that….don’t quote me word for word. That was supposedly her last comment before the scene was over. I don’t really know what to make of it, but you can take it for what it’s worth. They did all clap for Michaela when it was over saying it was a wrap for season 5 for her. I’m not sure if that was the last scene for 518 or just one of her scenes throughout the show. If I had to guess I would say it wasn’t the last. Hope this helps!

After the game Lucas does go to Tric, and he drinks a lot..as in shots. Skills is there and Peyton shows up, when Skills goes to leave he asks Peyton to make sure Lucas gets home okay. Hence she takes him home and the “IHY” happens. (5.17)

credit to Taylor@FF

Credit to CurlyHead @ Fan Forum
It’s been confirmed that Lucas is drinking at Tric (taking shots actually) and Peyton does come to pull him out of there to take him home. I know we assumed that, but it’s been confirmed. (5.17)

My friend was an extra at TRIC a few weeks ago and they filmed a scene where Skills/Deb realize that they have been set up together by an internet dating site or something. They are surprised to see each other. I guess he is sitting there with a rose or something and she comes up and says his screen name and she says hers and they turn around and are kind of like “OMG” Credit: tutorgirl323

Side Summaries

Scene 15: Brooke tells Lucas that the doctor said Angie’s surgery would take a while. Lucas then says that if it’s okay, he’ll wait with her. Brooke responds that she’d like that, since Peyton has to go and she’d be on her own otherwise. Peyton tries to argue that she’s not leaving, but Brooke is insistent that she has an insanely busy day and should go get things done. Peyton finally gives in and hugs Brooke, telling Brooke to call her as soon as she knows anything. As Peyton leaves, Lucas says goodbye to her. She looks at him for the first time since reading his book, before leaving and walking past an examination room.

Scene 16: Hospital. Examination Room. Dan Scott is meeting his doctor. The doctor explains that over the next few months he will feel more sluggish, and it’s important that he doesn’t push it. But the good news is that because of his size and blood type, Dan is second on the recipient list for a donor heart. The doctor then hands Dan a pager, telling him that he has to keep it with him 24 hours a day. If a heart becomes available, they’ll only have around six hours to place it. On hearing that he’s number two on the list, Dan asks how much it would cost him to be bumped up to number one. The doctor replies that Dan probably won’t be able to buy off Reverend Carter, who’s in pretty bad shape and is a good man. Dan takes offence at that, asking what the doctor means by “good man”. In response, the doctor eyes Dan before telling him they don’t discriminate when it comes to saving lives. It’s his job to give a heart to whoever needs it. Dan eyes the doctor back, before commenting that it doesn’t matter whether they’re a miracle worker or a murderer. The doctor leaves, and Dan considers what he has been told.

Scene 17: Peyton’s Office. Recording Studio. Peyton walks into the room and finds Haley taping a picture of Nathan and Jamie to the piano.

Scene 27: Start of Act Three. Peyton’s Office. Recording Studio. Mia speaks directly into the camera while wearing a “Rock The Vote” t-shirt. She says that it was a year of firsts for her, including her first chance to vote. If her voice is a gift, as people have said it is, so are the voices of everyone else. “So use it. Let it be heard. Rock The Vote.” Mia smiles, and the cameraman tells her it was perfect. Mia then thanks him when he compliments her album. The cameraman and boom operator then leave, passing Peyton who thanks them. Peyton turns to Mia, throwing her a packet of Starburst. Peyton tells Mia that her next tour will be the “Starburst Thursday night Concert Series”, at Six Flags. Mia responds that she loves Starburst, and she loves rollercoasters. Peyton agrees: “It’s very you.”

Scene 62: Dan tells Reverend Carter that the doc was right. He is in bad shape. A nurse then appears, and tells Dan that it’s after hours, before asking whether he’s a relative. With his back to the nurse, Dan says that he isn’t a relative…but the Reverend is number one on his list.

Scene 63: Lucas’ House. Peyton covers Lucas, who is unconscious, before stroking his hair. She tells him she’s sorry, and never wanted this for him. Leaning in, she kisses Lucas on the cheek, and his eyes open as she starts to turn away. When he calls out her name, Peyton turns back with a gentle smile on her face. Lucas then tells Peyton that he hates her, and wishes she had never come back, because she ruined his life. His words sink in as Peyton’s face falls, and she finally exits, leaving Lucas alone in the darkness. End of Episode. Credit 2TAC FF

Coach Todd

Ronnie

Scenes 30-36: Tree Hill High Gym. Tip Off, the Ravens against the Bear Creek Warriors. The Ravens win the tip and Quentin catches the ball in his… hand. The opposing coach, Coach Todd, taunts Lucas about letting a kid play with only one good hand. Lucas ignores him, and instead tells Q to keep going. As Q pushes upcourt, Mouth follows him with a camera from the bleachers. Q passes and the Ravens score a three pointer. The game continues on with scoring from both teams. Lucas substitutes players, and when questioned tells Coach Todd this is his “worst nightmare.” As the Ravens score another three, Nathan, Jamie and Skills cheer them on.

Scenes 40-41: Lucas’ Office. Lucas scans the half time statistics. His cell phone rings, and it’s Lindsey. Lucas tells her that they would have liked to see her at the game, but as he listens to her speak, he begins to look concerned. The camera moves outside the window so we can see Lucas talking, but we can’t hear what is said.

Scene 42: Tree Hill High Gym. Lucas is now angry and more severe than earlier in the game. He yells at Q, and when Q fails to do as he was told, Lucas calls for a time out and a huddle.

Scene 43: Ravens Huddle. Lucas gives a pep talk about nothing in life being easy. They’re going to win this game! With a Lucas-inspired chant of “Bear Creek Sucks!” they break the huddle. Skills looks at Nathan, and both are wary of Lucas’ behaviour.

Scene 44: Bear Creek Huddle. Coach Todd tells his players that the Ravens are taunting them – and they’re right to, their point guard only has one hand! He goes on to say that every time Q gets the ball, the team should foul him. He’ll either miss the free throws, or he’ll end up with both hands broken. The game starts back up, and Q is immediately fouled. Lucas argues that it was a flagrant foul, but the ref says it wasn’t. As Q steps to the free throw line, Skills looks at Lucas and Nathan, and knows what the Warriors are trying to do. They’re going to foul Q, and make him take left-handed free throws: “Hack-A-Shaq”. When Q proceeds to make both free throws, Coach Todd tells one of his players, Ronnie, to take out Q’s other wrist. As the game continues, Ronnie makes a beeline for Q, and fouls him hard on the wrist. The ref again doesn’t call the foul, as Quentin holds his wrist in pain. With Skills and Nathan beside him, Lucas glares angrily at the referee. He tells the ref that on the street, that would be assault! On the court, it’s not even a foul? The ref ignores him, which causes Luke to slam a ball down hard onto the court. The ref calls a technical foul on the Ravens, and Skills and Nathan try, but fail, to hold Lucas back as he walks after the ref. Lucas can’t believe the ref is going to call a foul on him for that, but completely blew an obvious call during the game! Ronnie, the player who fouled Q, chuckles as he walks past, and tells the ref to throw Lucas’ “dumb ass out.” Lucas grabs Ronnie by the jersey, causing the ref to blow his whistle and both teams to square off for a street fight. Nathan tells Jamie to go sit with Mouth, and he and Skills rush onto the court, dragging Q and Lucas away before they get hurt. Mouth sits on the sideline, continuing to film as he and Jamie watch the fight, shocked by what they’re witnessing. End of Act Three.

Source

Filming Info

tutorgirl323@FF: Antwon, Barbara, Chad, and Hilarie filmed at Tric today.

Credit to Nbetterbid @ othfourms:

Hey everyone. Went to C/B today and watched some filming. Ironically, Sophia was NOT there filming. Hilarie and Paul filmed separate scenes which I got some pics of. Then Hilarie and Joy filmed a scene on the roof top of some building. Didn’t see anything though since they were on top of a roof lol but I did see Joy walking around, holding hands with her husband. They looked adorable and happy. Anyway here are some pics. I’ll explain the scene they filmed under the pics.

This is Hilarie, Paul and Mark in between takes
http://i112.photobucket.com/albums/n…terbid/010.jpg

Then a few pics of Hilarie filming her scene. All it consisted of was her getting out of her car and running up to the front door of C/B to go in.
http://i112.photobucket.com/albums/n…terbid/016.jpg
http://i112.photobucket.com/albums/n…terbid/006.jpg

And then Paul filmed a rather funny scene. He’s walking down the sidewalk, gets a newspaper from the newspaper vendor on the street and is reading it as he walks. As he gets to about the front door of C/B, a water balloon splats right in front of him. He looks up and around to see who threw it. Then walks away.

http://i112.photobucket.com/albums/n…terbid/013.jpg

Credit tutorgirl323 @ FF

I was also at C/B today watching. I went back later in the day to see if I could catch any more filming and I saw them on the rooftop a little bit. I am almost positive that the rooftop was supposed to be the rooftop of C/B since that building is actually 5 or 6 stories high so they wouldn’t film it there. It looked like they were throwing the water balloons over the side of the roof, kind of matching up with what was filmed in front of C/B. In addition to Paul and Hilarie filming they also did a few shots where they turned some music on and had extras walk back and forth in front of C/B getting hit by a ton of water balloons. In the scene with Hilarie she would run out of her car and she was looking towards the roof, then as she made her way in the building, the camera tilted up towards the roof.

Here are some pics:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2…3/100_0645.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2…3/100_0646.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2…3/100_0647.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2…3/100_0650.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2…3/100_0651.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2…3/100_0652.jpg